- Adam DeVine as Andy Bailey
- Joe Mande as Ben
- Robbie Amell as Chase
- Michael Bunin as Director
- Laura Ashley Samuels as Beth
- Chris Farah as Teacher
- Millie Brown as Lizze
- Jeremy Scott Johnson as Andrew
- Matt McGrath as Simon
- Jenny Marlowe as Nurse
- Zola Odessa as Naomi
- Andrew's third appearance ("Undeck the Halls", "Regrets Only").
- Andy's tenth appearance.
- This episode marks the first on-screen appearance of Beth, Andy's girlfriend, who was previously mentioned in "A Fair to Remember", "Other People's Children", "The Wedding (Part 1)", "The Wedding (Part 2)", "The Cold", and "Queer Eyes, Full Hearts".
- Aside from a few interview scenes, the Dunphy household does not appear in this episode.
- Alex does not appear in the episode.
- Jay's old closet commercial is shown in widescreen 16:9 even though widescreen television would not have existed at the time.